Research Progress on Suppression of Slow Scintillation Component in Barium Fluoride Crystal by Doping

Abstract

Abstract: Applications, such as high energy physics experiments at intensity frontier, time-of-flight positron emission tomography, ultrahigh repetition radiation imaging, and positron annihilation lifetime spectroscopy, etc., have raised increasing demands on the time response of scintillators. Development of ultrafast scintillators becomes one of focuses in recent studies. Barium fluoride (BaF₂) crystal is a unique ultrafast scintillator with a sub-nanosecond fast scintillation component, its slow scintillation component with a decay time of about 0.6 μs, however, will cause serious pileups at high counting rates. As an effective approach to suppress the slow component in BaF₂ crystals, doping has attracted continuous attention over the past three decades. This paper reviews the history of suppression of slow component in BaF₂ crystals by doping, and then proposes basic principles on selecting doping elements. Suppression characteristic and mechanisms of slow component in BaF₂ crystals doped with rare-earth metals (La, Y, Lu, Sc), alkali earth metals (Mg, Sr), transition metal (Cd), and alkali metal (K) are highlighted, and application research is introduced. The challenge and opportunity of slow component suppression by doping are also prospected.

Key words: barium fluoride, ultrafast scintillator, inorganic scintillation crystal, slow component suppression, doping, scintillation property, suppression mechanism

CLC Number:

O734
TL812

ZHENG Jiaqian, CHEN Junfeng, LI Xiang, LU Baoqi, FENG He. Research Progress on Suppression of Slow Scintillation Component in Barium Fluoride Crystal by Doping[J]. Journal of Synthetic Crystals, 2022, 51(6): 951-964.

References

[1] PEZZULLO G, BUDAGOV J, CAROSI R, et al. Progress status for the Mu2e calorimeter system[J]. Journal of Physics: Conference Series, 2015, 587: 012047.
[2] WANG Z H, GUARDINCERRI E, RATHMAN D D, et al. Gigahertz (GHz) hard X-ray imaging using fast scintillators[C]//SPIE Optical Engineering+Applications. Proc SPIE 8852, Hard X-Ray, Gamma-Ray, and Neutron Detector Physics XV, San Diego, California, USA. 2013, 8852: 192-204.
[3] YANG F, CHEN J F, ZHANG L Y, et al. La-and La-/ Ce-doped BaF₂ crystals for future HEP experiments at the energy and intensity frontiers part I[J]. IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, 2019, 66(1): 506-511.
[4] ZHU R Y. Ultrafast and radiation hard inorganic scintillators for future HEP experiments[J]. Journal of Physics: Conference Series, 2019, 1162: 012022.
[5] YIN Y R, WANG G J, JIA Z T, et al. Controllable and directional growth of Er∶Lu₂O₃ single crystals by the edge-defined film-fed technique[J]. CrystEngComm, 2020, 22(39): 6569-6573.
[6] ERMIS E E, CELIKTAS C. Effects of the positions of scintillation detectors with fast scintillators and photomultiplier tubes on TOF-PET performance[J]. Pramana, 2020, 94(1): 1-9.
[7] LECOQ P, MOREL C, PRIOR J O, et al. Roadmap toward the 10 ps time-of-flight PET challenge[J]. Physics in Medicine and Biology, 2020, 65(21): 21RM01.
[8] GUNDACKER S, MARTINEZ TURTOS R, KRATOCHWIL N, et al. Experimental time resolution limits of modern SiPMs and TOF-PET detectors exploring different scintillators and Cherenkov emission[J]. Physics in Medicine and Biology, 2020, 65(2): 025001.
[9] HU C, ZHANG L Y, ZHU R Y, et al. Ultrafast inorganic scintillator-based front imager for Gigahertz hard X-ray imaging[J]. Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment, 2019, 940: 223-229.
[10] VAN EIJK C W E. Cross-luminescence[J]. Journal of Luminescence, 1994, 60/61: 936-941.
[11] RODNYI P, GARIBIN E, VENEVTSEV I, et al. The application of barium fluoride luminescence: challenges and prospects[J]. St Petersburg Polytechnical State University Journal: Physics and Mathematics, 2019, 12(1): 9-24.
[12] LAVAL M, MOSZYN＇SKI M, ALLEMAND R, et al. Barium fluoride: inorganic scintillator for subnanosecond timing: nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research, 1983, 206(1/2): 169-176.
[13] SCHOTANUS P, VAN EIJK C W E, HOLLANDER R W, et al. Development study of a new gamma camera[J]. IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, 1987, 34(1): 271-276.
[14] GUNDACKER S, POTS R H, NEPOMNYASHCHIKH A, et al. Vacuum ultraviolet silicon photomultipliers applied to BaF₂ cross-luminescence detection for high-rate ultrafast timing applications[J]. Physics in Medicine & Biology, 2021, 66(11): 114002.
[15] ALEKSANDROV Y M, MAKHOV V N, RODNYI P A, et al. Intrinsic luminescence of BaF₂ on the pulse excitation by synchrotron radiation[J]. Sov Phys Solid State, 1984, 26: 1734-1736.
[16] VALBIS Y A, RACHKO Z A, YANSONS Y L. Short-wave UV luminescence of BaF₂ crystals caused by crossover transitions[J]. Jetp Letters, 1985: 42.
[17] ZHU R Y. Barium fluoride crystals for precision EMC at SSC[M]// Phyllis Hale. Supercollider 5. Boston: Springer, 1994: 411-414.
[18] ZHU R Y. Crystal calorimeters in the next decade[J]. Physics Procedia, 2012, 37: 372-383.
[19] TSCHIRHART R. The Mu2e experiment at fermilab[J]. Nuclear Physics B-Proceedings Supplements, 2011, 210/211: 245-248.
[20] FARUKHI M R, SWINEHART C F. Barium fluoride as a gamma ray and charged particle detector[J]. IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, 1971, 18(1): 200-204.
[21] SCHOTANUS P, VAN EIJK C W E, HOLLANDER R W, et al. Photoelectron production in BaF₂-TMAE detectors[J]. Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment, 1987, 259(3): 586-588.
[22] BEAUMONT J, HAYES W, KIRK D, et al. An investigation of trapped holes and trapped excitons in alkaline earth fluorides[J]. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London A Mathematical and Physical Sciences, 1970, 315(1520): 69-97.
[23] WILLIAMS R T, KABLER M N, HAYES W, et al. Time-resolved spectroscopy of self-trapped excitons in fluorite crystals[J]. Physical Review B, 1976, 14(2): 725-740.
[24] WOODY C L, LEVY P W, KIERSTEAD J A. Slow component suppression and radiation damage in doped BaF₂/crystals[J]. IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, 1989, 36(1): 536-542.
[25] VISVIKIS D, OTT R J, WELLS K, et al. Performance characterisation of large area BaF₂-TMAE detectors for use in a whole body clinical PET camera[J]. Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment, 1997, 392(1/2/3): 414-420.
[26] MEHTA S, NAYAK T K, BRAR L. Time of flight (TOF)-positron emission tomography (PET) imaging using 5-gap glass multi-gap resistive plate chambers (MRPCs)[D]. 2016
[27] BISWAS D C, VIND R P, KUMAR N, et al. Fission fragment velocity distribution measurement using time of flight technique[J]. Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment, 2018, 901: 76-83.
[28] POTS R H, AUFFRAY E, GUNDACKER S. Exploiting cross-luminescence in BaF₂ for ultrafast timing applications using deep-ultraviolet sensitive HPK silicon photomultipliers[J]. Frontiers in Physics, 2020, 8: 592875.
[29] ZHANG L Y, HU C, OYANG J, et al. QE/PDE of VUV photodetectors for BaF₂ readout[C]//2020 IEEE Nuclear Science Symposium and Medical Imaging Conference. October 31-November 7, 2020, Boston, MA, USA. IEEE, 2020: 1-2.
[30] DEVOL T A. Evaluation of wavelength shifters for spectral separation of barium fluoride emissions[R]. Office of Scientific and Technical Information (OSTI), 1993.
[31] 顾牡,马晓辉,徐荣昆,等.加载光子带隙膜系BaF₂晶体闪烁光慢成分抑制和抗γ辐照损伤的研究[J].强激光与粒子束,2005,17(1):42-46.
GU M, MA X H, XU R K, et al. Slow component suppression and γ radiation hardness of BaF₂ crystal modified by photonic band multilayer filter[J]. High Power Laser & Particle Beams, 2005, 17(1): 42-46(in Chinese).
[32] 马晓辉,顾牡,徐荣昆,等.抑制BaF₂晶体闪烁光慢成分的选择吸收膜系的研究[J].无机材料学报,2004,19(3):666-670.
MA X H, GU M, XU R K, et al. Metal/dielectric multilayers filter to suppress the slow component of the scintillation light in BaF₂ crystal[J]. Journal of Inorganic Materials, 2004, 19(3): 666-670(in Chinese).
[33] ARTIKOV A M, BARANOV V, BUDAGOV J A, et al. Suppression of the slow component of BaF₂ crystal luminescence with a thin multilayer filter[J]. Journal of Physics: Conference Series, 2019, 1162: 012028.
[34] 张子川,韩和同,管兴胤,等.基于反射滤光方法的氟化钡快响应γ射线探测技术[J].现代应用物理,2013,4(3):225-231.
ZHANG Z C, HAN H T, GUAN X Y, et al. BaF₂ detector with fast time response for γ-ray pulse measurement based on ultraviolet band-pass optical filter[J]. Modern Applied Physics, 2013, 4(3): 225-231(in Chinese).
[35] BIASINI M, CASSIDY D B, DENG S H M, et al. Suppression of the slow component of scintillation light in BaF₂[J]. Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment, 2005, 553(3): 550-558.
[36] SCHOTANUS P, DORENBOS P, VAN EIJK C W E, et al. Suppression of the slow scintillation light output of BaF₂ crystals by La³⁺ doping[J]. Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment, 1989, 281(1): 162-166.
[37] DORENBOS P, VISSER R, DOOL R, et al. Suppression of self-trapped exciton luminescence in La³⁺-and Nd³⁺-doped BaF₂[J]. Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter, 1992, 4(23): 5281-5290.
[38] REN S X, CHEN G, ZHANG F Y, et al. The effect of impurities on the radiation damage of Barium fluoride crystal[J]. MRS Proceedings, 1994, 348: 435.
[39] VISSER R, DORENBOS P, EIJK CWE, et al. Scintillation properties of Ce³⁺ doped BaF₂ crystals[J]. IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, 1991, 38(2): 127-131.
[40] DORENBOS P, VISSER R, HOLLANDER R W, et al. The effects of La³⁺ and Ce³⁺ dopants on the scintillation properties of BaF₂ crystals[J]. Radiation Effects and Defects in Solids, 1991, 119/120/121(1): 87-92.
[41] GARIBIN E A, GAIN S D, GUSEV P E, et al. New scintillators based on barium fluoride crystals and ceramics[J]. Bulletin of the Russian Academy of Sciences: Physics, 2011, 75(7): 1011-1014.
[42] CHEN G, XIAO H, MAN S Q, et al. Radiation damage of rare earth ions doped barium fluoride crystals[M]// John Nonte. Supercollider 4. Boston: Springer, 1992: 809-815.
[43] DROZDOWSKI W, WOJTOWICZ A J. Radiative recombination in BaF₂∶Pr[J]. Journal of Alloys and Compounds, 2000, 300/301: 261-266.
[44] WOJTOWICZ A J, SZUPRYCZYNSKI P, DROZDOWSKI W. Radiative recombination in Ce-, Pr-, and Tb-doped barium fluoride[J]. Journal of Alloys and Compounds, 2000, 300/301: 199-206.
[45] RADZHABOV E, NAGIRNYI V. Excitation of Pr³⁺ions in alkaline-earth fluorides[J]. IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering, 2010, 15: 012029.
[46] SHENDRIK R, RADZHABOV E, NAGIRNYI V. Time-resolved spectroscopy of 5d-4f transitions in Pr³⁺doped alkali-earth fluorides[J]. IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering, 2010, 15: 012083.
[47] KAWAGUCHI N, YANAGIDA T, FUTAMI Y, et al. Nd concentration dependence on the optical and scintillation properties of Nd doped BaF₂[J]. Optical Materials, 2010, 32(10): 1325-1328.
[48] RADZHABOV E, NAGIRNYI V, KIRM M, et al. 5d-4f emission of Nd³⁺, Sm³⁺, Ho³⁺, Er³⁺, Tm³⁺ ions in alkaline earth fluorides[J]. IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, 2012, 59(5): 2074-2078.
[49] 沈定中,刘建成,袁湘龙,等.BaF₂∶Ce,La,Eu晶体的光谱性质[J].无机材料学报,1994,9(3):281-287.
SHEN D Z, LIU J C, YUAN X L, et al. Spectra properties of BaF₂∶Ce, La, Eu crystals[J]. Journal of Inorganic Materials, 1994, 9(3): 281-287(in Chinese).
[50] FERRAZ G M, MATSUOKA M, WATANABE S, et al. Radiation effects on BaF₂ crystals[J]. Radiation Effects and Defects in Solids, 1998, 146(1/2/3/4): 303-309.
[51] KIRM M, STRYGANYUK G, VIELHAUER S, et al. Vacuum-ultraviolet 5d-4f luminescence of Gd³⁺and Lu³⁺ions in fluoride matrices[J]. Physical Review B, 2007, 75(7): 075111.
[52] RADZHABOV E A, PROSEKINA E A. 5d-4f luminescence of Nd³⁺, Gd³⁺, Er³⁺, Tm³⁺, and Ho³⁺ ions in crystals of alkaline earth fluorides[J]. Optics and Spectroscopy, 2011, 111(3): 397-402.
[53] ABE N, YOKOTA Y, YANAGIDA T, et al. Evaluation of gamma-ray response of Tm∶BaF₂ single crystals[J]. IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, 2010, 57(3): 1304-1307.
[54] SELIVERSTOV D M, DEMIDENKO A A, GARIBIN E A, et al. New fast scintillators on the base of BaF₂ crystals with increased light yield of 0.9 ns luminescence for TOF PET[J]. Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment, 2012, 695: 369-372.
[55] SHI G S, XIE Z J, DENG J, et al. Thermoluminescence of BaF₂∶Re(Ce, Dy, Eu) crystals[J]. Journal of Electron Spectroscopy and Related Phenomena, 1996, 79: 87-90.
[56] STEF M, NICOARA I, VIZMAN D. Distribution of Yb³⁺ and Yb²⁺ ions along YbF₃-doped BaF₂ crystals[J]. Crystal Research and Technology, 2018, 53(12): 1800186.
[57] DOUALAN J L, CAMY P, BENAYAD A, et al. Spectroscopic and laser properties of Yb³⁺ doped CaF₂, SrF₂ and BaF₂ laser crystals[C]//Advanced Solid-State Photonics. Nara. Washington, D.C.: OSA, 2008.
[58] NESTERKINA V, SHIRAN N, GEKTIN A, et al. The Lu-doping effect on the emission and the coloration of pure and Ce-doped BaF₂ crystals[J]. Radiation Measurements, 2007, 42(4/5): 819-822.
[59] SOBOLEV B P, KRIVANDINA E A, DERENZO S E, et al. Suppression of BaF₂ slow component of X-ray luminescence in non-stoichiometric Ba_0.9R_0.1F_2.1 crystals (R=Rare earth element)[J]. MRS Proceedings, 1994, 348: 277.
[60] RADZHABOV E, KIRM M, EGRANOV A, et al. Mechanism of exciton suppression in alkali-earth fluorides doped with La, Y, Cd[J]. Proc SCINT 2005, 2005: 60-63.
[61] CHEN J F, YANG F, ZHANG L Y, et al. Slow scintillation suppression in yttrium doped BaF₂ crystals[J]. IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, 2018, 65(8): 2147-2151.
[62] HU C, XU C, ZHANG L Y, et al. Development of yttrium-doped BaF₂ crystals for future HEP experiments[J]. IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, 2019, 66(7): 1854-1860.
[63] HU C, ZHANG L Y, ZHU R Y, et al. BaF₂∶Y and ZnO∶Ga crystal scintillators for GHz hard X-ray imaging[J]. Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment, 2020, 950: 162767.
[64] 王红锋,刘福雁,王英杰,等.掺钇BaF₂闪烁探测器性能研究[J].核技术,2020,43(3):21-26.
WANG H F, LIU F Y, WANG Y J, et al. Study on performance of Yttrium doped BaF₂ scintillation detector[J]. Nuclear Techniques, 2020, 43(3): 21-26(in Chinese).
[65] KOBAYASHI M, ISHII M, SOBOLEV B P, et al. Scintillation characteristics of nonstoichiometric phases formed in MF₂-GdF₃-CeF₃ system Part I. (M=Ba), scintillation of Ba_0.9Gd_0.1-xCe_xF_2.1 (0≤x≤0.1) fluorite-type crystals[J]. Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment, 1999, 421(1/2): 180-190.
[66] WOJTOWICZ A J, JANUS S, PIATKOWSKI D. Fast and efficient VUV/UV emissions from (Ba, La)F₂∶Er crystals[J]. Journal of Luminescence, 2009, 129(12): 1594-1597.
[67] YANG F, CHEN J F, ZHANG L Y, et al. La-and La-/Ce-doped BaF₂ crystals for future HEP experiments at the energy and intensity frontiers part Ⅱ[J]. IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, 2019, 66(1): 512-518.
[68] KUROSAWA S, YANAGIDA T, YOKOTA Y, et al. Crystal growth and scintillation properties of fluoride scintillators[J]. IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, 2012, 59(5): 2173-2176.
[69] HAMADA M M. Auger-free luminescence of the BaF₂∶Sr, BaF₂∶MgF₂ and CsBr∶LiBr crystals under excitation of VUV photons and high-energy electrons[J]. Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment, 1994, 340(3): 524-539.
[70] HAMADA M M, NUNOYA Y, SAKURAGUI S, et al. Suppression of the slow component of BaF₂ crystal by introduction of SrF₂ and MgF₂ crystals[J]. Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment, 1994, 353(1/2/3): 33-36.
[71] 古佩新,胡关钦,华素坤,等.掺杂氟化钡晶体的γ辐照损伤[J].人工晶体学报,1993,22(2):152-156.
GU P X, HU G Q, HUA S K, et al. Effects of dopants on γ-irradiation damage of BaF₂ crystal[J]. Journal of Synthetic Crystals, 1993, 22(2): 152-156(in Chinese).
[72] SPRINGIS M, VEISPALS A, KULIS P, et al. Optical and spectral properties of the Cd-containing BaF₂[C]. SCINT95: Proc Int Conf on Inorganic Scintillators and their Applications, 1995: 403-406.
[73] RADZHABOV E, MYSOVSKY A, EGRANOV A, et al. Cadmium centres in alkaline-earth fluoride crystals[J]. Physica Status Solidi (c), 2005, 2(1): 388-391.
[74] RADZHABOV E, ISTOMIN A, NEPOMNYASHIKH A, et al. Exciton interaction with impurity in barium fluoride crystals[J]. Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment, 2005, 537(1/2): 71-75.
[75] DORENBOS P, VISSER R, VAN EIJK C W E, et al. X-ray and gamma ray luminescence of Ce³⁺ doped BaF₂ crystals[J]. Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment, 1991, 310(1/2): 236-239.
[76] RODNYI P A, GAIN S D, GARIBIN E A, et al. Scintillators based on BaF₂ with improved performance[J]. IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, 2012, 59(5): 2168-2172.
[77] 陈俊锋,李翔,杜勇,等.大尺寸高质量掺钇氟化钡闪烁晶体的透光特性[J].人工晶体学报,2019,48(8):1403-1404.
CHEN J F, LI X, DU Y, et al. Optical transmittance of large, high quality Y doped barium fluoride scintillation crystals[J]. Journal of Synthetic Crystals, 2019, 48(8): 1403-1404(in Chinese).
[78] ANDERSON D F, BOUCLIER R, CHARPAK G, et al. Coupling of a BaF₂ scintillator to a TMAE photocathode and a low-pressure wire chamber[J]. Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research, 1983, 217(1/2): 217-223.
[79] SCHOTANUS P, DORENBOS P, VAN EIJK C W E, et al. Recent developments in scintillator research[J]. IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, 1989, 36(1): 132-136.
[80] 顾牡, 郑万辉. 掺镧抑制氟化钡晶体闪烁光慢闪烁成分的机理研究[J].核技术,1995,18(7):391-394.
GU M, ZHENG W H. Study on the mechanism of lanthanum doping inhibiting the slow scintillation component of barium fluoride crystal[J]. Nuclear Technology, 1995, 18(7): 391-394(in Chinese).
[81] 顾牡,陈玲燕.掺镧氟化钡晶体的闪烁光慢成分抑制特性[J].同济大学学报(自然科学版),1996,24(1):81.
GU M, CHEN L Y. Suppression characteristics of slow component of scintillation light in lanthanum doped barium fluoride crystal [J]. Journal of Tongji University, 1996, 24(1): 81(in Chinese).
[82] HU C, ZHANG L Y, ZHU R Y, et al. Spatial resolution of an inorganic crystal-based hard X-ray imager[J]. IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, 2020, 67(6): 1014-1019.
[83] HU C, ZHANG L Y, ZHU R Y, et al. Temporal response of fast and ultrafast inorganic scintillators[C]//2018 IEEE Nuclear Science Symposium and Medical Imaging Conference Proceedings. November 10-17, 2018, Sydney, NSW, Australia. IEEE, 2018: 1-2.